Cookies with
a little extra.
More Than Sugar Co. creates thick, bakery-style cookies. From our signature chocolate chip to rotating specialty flavors, every cookie brings something a little extra to the table.
Big cookie energy.Made a little extra
Meet the cookies.
Our familiar favorites and a rotating lineup of specialty flavors. Each one deserves its own moment.
Cookies for the moments that matter.
Office celebrations, client thank-yous, gatherings with your favorite people. We make larger orders feel just as special as a single treat.
Tell us what you're planning and we'll help you find the right mix.
Catering & Corporate Orders →More ways to share.
Gather. Gift. Celebrate.
Thoughtfully made cookie orders for teams, corporate gifts, birthdays, showers, and everything in between.
Explore catering →Something sweet for your shelves.
Interested in serving More Than Sugar Co. cookies? Let's talk about a wholesale partnership that fits your business.
Explore wholesale →Our cookies.
Thick, bakery-style cookies, made to be a little extra. Flavors rotate, so check Hotplate for what's in the next drop.
Something for every craving.
Cookies, your way.
All ordering and payment happens on our Hotplate storefront. Discover the latest drops and choose your pickup options there.
Your next cookie fix is just a few clicks away.
- 01Browse the current drop.Find the cookies available right now on our Hotplate page.
- 02Choose your cookies.Select what's available, your quantities, and pickup details.
- 03Check out on Hotplate.Place your order and complete payment securely through Hotplate.
Catering &
corporate orders.
Elevate office celebrations, client gifts, special occasions, and gatherings with thick, bakery-style cookies.
A little extra for the whole crowd.
Whether you are celebrating a team, hosting an event, or thanking your favorite clients, we'll help create an order that suits the occasion.
24-cookie specialty box
Flavor minimum: Generally 12 cookies per flavor. Larger orders and customized combinations are quoted individually.
Request a catering quote.
Share a few details below and we will review your request.
Tell us about your shop.
Share where you're located and what your customers love.
Discuss the right fit.
We'll review flavors, estimated quantities, and logistics together.
Build something sweet.
Partnership details and wholesale pricing are provided privately.
Made for your customers.
From coffee shop counters to local retail spaces, our cookies make a memorable addition to the everyday treat menu.
Columbia, PA
Wholesale pricing is shared directly with prospective partners after an inquiry.
Meet us on Dot Profile ↗Wholesale inquiry.
We would love to learn more about your business. Send your inquiry directly to our bakery.
More than just
a cookie.
Artisan baked goods, made to be remembered.
At More Than Sugar Co., we believe a great cookie is about more than just sweetness. It's about the quality of ingredients, moments, memories, and connections that come with it.
What started as a passion for baking has grown into a small, locally owned artisan bakery specializing in thick, bakery-style cookies made to be a little extra in every way. From our classic Chocolate Chip to our rotating specialty flavors, each cookie is thoughtfully crafted to bring something special to the table.
We love taking familiar favorites and giving them our own twist, combining rich flavors, delicious fillings, and signature toppings to create cookies worth looking forward to.
As a growing small business, we're proud to share our cookies with our local community through our farm stand, local coffee shop partnerships, events, and special orders. Every order, every visit, and every recommendation helps us grow, and we're grateful to everyone who has become part of our journey.
Because at More Than Sugar Co., it's never just about the cookie. It's about the little things that make life sweeter.
More Than Sugar Co.
Artisan Baked Goods, Made to Be Remembered.
Find us &
say hello.
Questions, special orders, partnership ideas, or just want to keep up with the next cookie drop? We'd love to connect.
Let's connect.
See current offerings and pickup options directly on Hotplate.
Our Dot Profile brings all of our business and social links together in one place.
What can we help with?
Use the form to send a message to the bakery. For catering or wholesale, our dedicated request forms collect more details.